Forums.NitroExpress.com

Home | Ezine | Forums | Links | Contact NitroExpress.com: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "

View recent messages : 24 hours | 48 hours | 7 days | 14 days | 30 days | 60 days | More Smilies

*** Enjoy NitroExpress.com? Participate and join in. ***

You are not logged in. [Login]

Main Index · Search · Active Topics
New user · Who's Online · FAQ · Calendar

Shooting & Reloading - Mausers, Big Bores and others >> Rifles

9.3x57
.450 member

Reged: 22/04/07
Posts: 5520
Loc: United States

Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "
18/12/07 05:17 AM

If anybody here is saying "It won't work!" my question is "How do you know?"

I mean, I don't hear Daryl stating that the heavily loaded .45-70 is the "greatest buff cartridge on earth", and I know I am not.

But to criticise a guy's experimentation {that seemed to work OK by the way} without any field reports otherwise seems to be a weak argument. I say if a fellow can get a PH to let him, test the .45-70 extensively and then let's find out how it does. I simply do not know as I have not read much about heavy-loaded .45-70's on heavy African game.

My point is that I would love to see Daryl's or Sam's loads tested on a number of big critters and then maybe an argument could be made for or against it.

I was thinking that one of the Aussies here had some {not so good?} experiences with heavy-loaded .45-70's but maybe my memory is unclear on that point. I'd love to hear from others with pro and con reports. I myself am undecided. I have shot a lot of cast 400-420 grain bullets in a variety of media and they penetrate surprisingly well. I must dig out my records, as IIRC, my 402 grain HP load penetrated as far as the recent premium .375 loads tested. I'll check and report later.

Oh, yeah, Peter...Daryl is doing a great job of stumping for the .45-70 but he ain't from the US...

--------------------
What are the Rosary, the Cross or the Crucifix other than tools to help maintain the fortress of our faith in Jesus Christ, the Son of God?

Post Extras

Print Post

Remind Me!

Notify Moderator

Entire topic
Subject	Posted by	Posted on
"45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	16/12/07 05:39 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Ripp	16/12/07 05:45 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	16/12/07 10:14 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	18/12/07 11:08 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	18/12/07 01:10 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	19/12/07 02:06 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	19/12/07 08:28 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	19/12/07 12:31 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	19/12/07 02:41 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	19/12/07 02:55 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	allenday	21/12/07 09:55 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	22/12/07 01:25 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	allenday	22/12/07 03:49 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	22/12/07 04:34 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	rigbymauser	27/12/07 02:11 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	22/12/07 10:29 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	23/12/07 01:19 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	buckbrush	24/12/07 04:53 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	25/12/07 04:15 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	451whitworth	25/12/07 12:09 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	26/12/07 02:50 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	NitroX	26/12/07 07:02 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	27/12/07 01:13 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	27/12/07 03:00 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	BFaucett	27/12/07 09:17 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	22/01/08 06:33 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Bramble	22/01/08 08:33 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	22/01/08 12:03 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Bramble	22/01/08 12:38 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	500grains	22/01/08 02:02 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	451whitworth	27/12/07 12:45 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	NitroX	27/12/07 02:38 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	peter	27/12/07 04:52 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Ripp	27/12/07 02:17 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	451whitworth	22/12/07 11:15 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	22/12/07 01:47 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	smicha6551	22/12/07 05:23 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	23/12/07 01:01 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	smicha6551	23/12/07 04:11 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	23/12/07 09:06 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Tatume	22/12/07 04:33 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	22/12/07 12:51 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	19/12/07 03:44 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	20/12/07 03:41 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	21/12/07 01:00 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	20/12/07 02:03 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	20/12/07 03:53 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	19/12/07 09:00 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	17/12/07 09:17 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	SubDoc	28/12/07 06:47 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	22/01/08 03:54 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xausa	22/01/08 05:19 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	22/01/08 11:54 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	22/01/08 05:15 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	22/01/08 11:42 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	22/01/08 06:44 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	23/01/08 12:33 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DDouble	23/01/08 01:28 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	23/01/08 02:42 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	23/01/08 05:00 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	23/01/08 10:44 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	24/01/08 12:23 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	24/01/08 02:50 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	500grains	24/01/08 03:53 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	24/01/08 09:32 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	25/01/08 05:05 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	25/01/08 08:46 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	reflex264	24/01/08 12:37 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	24/01/08 01:15 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	24/01/08 08:00 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	25/01/08 04:19 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	hoppdoc	25/01/08 10:04 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	04/02/08 08:06 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	24/01/08 12:20 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	24/01/08 02:43 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	23/01/08 10:33 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xausa	23/01/08 04:02 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	xring	23/01/08 10:38 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	reflex264	23/01/08 12:59 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	23/01/08 05:34 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	18/12/07 12:12 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	18/12/07 12:34 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	17/12/07 10:43 PM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	18/12/07 12:40 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	9.3x57	18/12/07 05:17 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	peter	18/12/07 07:12 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	18/12/07 08:18 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	Sarg	18/12/07 08:36 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	peter	18/12/07 01:52 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	DarylS	18/12/07 03:14 AM
Re: "45-70 is the way to go from Ele to T Rex "	JabaliHunter	18/12/07 03:38 AM

Extra information

0 registered and 13 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 19329

Jump to

NitroExpress.com

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.5

Home | Ezine | Forums | Links | Contact

Copyright 2003 to 2011 - all rights reserved