buckstix
(.400 member)
25/02/23 02:50 AM
HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello All,

I bought a rifle last week and have no clue what I bought. I haven't received it yet. Probably will be 2 weeks before I get it in hand.
I would like to find out what the caliber is so I can buy brass and dies in preparation for its arrival. Its a 98 Mauser and it was listed as "Austrian Johann Peterlongo 11mm cal rifle.
The markings on the left side show a proofing 2,67 g G.B.P. / St.m.G. (see picture) Does this help to identify what the caliber might be? Your comments would be most welcome.





kuduae
(.400 member)
25/02/23 03:30 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

That 2,67 gramm = 41 gr rifle flake powder / steel jacket bullet” service load would be on spot for a 8x57I with the original 14.7 g = 227 gr bullet. I don’t know about any German “11 mm” cartridge with such a low service load. Even the smallest, the 10.75x57, was loaded with 3.5 g = 54 gr of the same powder. Maybe the barrel was replaced or rebored by Peterlongo in Austria? If so, there should be Austrian proofmarks below the wood.

buckstix
(.400 member)
25/02/23 03:38 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello kuduae,
Thanks for the reply.

I was suspecting that was the standard marking for an 8x57. I sure hope that it turns out that the barrel was replaced or rebored by Johann Peterlongo,
to some kind of an 11mm caliber. Perhaps a 10.75x68, or an 11.2x60 or an 11.2x72? Otherwise I paid a "very high" price for an ordinary 8x57 sporter.
I guess I'll have to wait to see what I bought. Thanks again.


kuduae
(.400 member)
25/02/23 04:25 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

As it is a pre-WW1 rifle, built on a Mauser, Oberndorf commercial action, two originally Austrian chamberings are possible too, the 10.75x63 and the 10.75x52 Roth / Springer. J.Peterlongo, Innsbruck, Austria, was then run by Richard Mahrholdt.

DarylS
(.700 member)
25/02/23 05:28 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

The original stock on my 9.3x62 looked identical to this rifle. Some of the front receiver ring engraving is the same as well.
I realize this doesn't help with your question, buckstix, sorry for the intrusion if this is a bother to you.


themauserkid
(.275 member)
25/02/23 06:36 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

10.75x61 is another possibility.

kuduae
(.400 member)
25/02/23 07:41 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Just a terrible suspicion came to my mind: Perhaps the barrel is still in 8x57I, but the muzzle is backbored to about 11 mm. Doing this was a common practice to salvage a barrel eith a worn out muzzle, but preserving the original front sight base. The seller of the rifle may have looked at the muzzle only and guessed at "about 11 mm".

buckstix
(.400 member)
25/02/23 10:59 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello kuduae,
Thanks for the reply.

I sure hope that is not the case. ? ? ? .... I likely paid 3 times the value of an 8x57 because it was advertised as an 11mm ... Here is the listing ...

" .... Item Description:

AUSTRIAN JOHANN PETERLONGO 11mm CAL RIFLE | Austrian Johann Peterlongo 11mm caliber bolt action rifle. 23" full rib barrel stamped "Johann Peterlongo Jnnsbruch Tirol". Austrian proofs. Blued finish. Checkered wood stock. Flip leaf rear sight. Double set trigger. Sling mounts. | Caliber / Ga 11mm | Barrel Length 23" | Serial Number NSN | Condition: Overall good. Light wear and oxidation. Bore is very good with light wear. Mechanically very good. ...."


DarylS
(.700 member)
25/02/23 03:20 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

I see 11mm 3 times in the add. But the question is, what 11mm ctg. could it be in a 98 Mauser?

NitroXAdministrator
(.700 member)
25/02/23 06:52 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Good luck. Hope it works out and waiting to see when it arrives.

No great academic knowledge but when I hear of Germanic 11 mm rifles I think of German East Africa/Tanganyika/Tanzania.

I'll have to search what cartridge I am thinking of.

A pre war WW1 Mauser would be right as well.

Irrespectively, a nice looking Mauser.


Hunter4752001
(.300 member)
25/02/23 06:57 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

The firm was known to make rifles in 11.2 x 72 Schuler as well as a few proprietary calibres. The 11.2x72 Schuler used a rebated case head to suit the 98 action. Allegedly a popular African big game cartridge in the German protectorates of the time. Bertram make brass for it.

Cartridge dimensions at
https://loaddata.com/Cartridge/112x72-Schuler/3060


lancaster
(.470 member)
25/02/23 08:13 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

a chamber cast will tell the truth

Mahrhold and Schüler were friends and a lot of this Mahrhold/Peterlongo rifles came from Suhl


kuduae
(.400 member)
25/02/23 08:42 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

" .... Item Description: AUSTRIAN JOHANN PETERLONGO 11mm CAL RIFLE | Austrian Johann Peterlongo 11mm caliber bolt action rifle. 23" full rib barrel stamped "Johann Peterlongo Jnnsbruch Tirol". Austrian proofs. ...."



Austrian proofs? I see a German, Suhl or Zella-Mehlis, 8x57I service load information only so far.


NitroXAdministrator
(.700 member)
25/02/23 08:52 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

The firm was known to make rifles in 11.2 x 72 Schuler as well as a few proprietary calibres. The 11.2x72 Schuler used a rebated case head to suit the 98 action. Allegedly a popular African big game cartridge in the German protectorates of the time. Bertram make brass for it.

Cartridge dimensions at
https://loaddata.com/Cartridge/112x72-Schuler/3060






.439 calibre, 400 gr 2100 fps to 2400 fps.

Similar to a .404 Jeffery in power?


buckstix
(.400 member)
25/02/23 10:37 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

per kuduae ....."Just a terrible suspicion came to my mind: Perhaps the barrel is still in 8x57I, but the muzzle is backbored to about 11 mm.
Doing this was a common practice to salvage a barrel with a worn out muzzle, but preserving the original front sight base.
The seller of the rifle may have looked at the muzzle only and guessed at "about 11 mm".



Hello All,
Thanks for the reply.

If the rifle turns out to be an ordinary 8x57I with an altered muzzle as mentioned above by kuduae, I am really going to be pissed.

I paid a BIG premium for a prewar 11mm Big Game rifle. I collect Big Game rifles, not 8x57 sporters.

Also, I assumed the caliber was going to be 11.2x72 Schuler as that is the only 11mm I found commonly associated with Johann Peterlongo.
I spent over $500 to buy dies and 100 pcs of brass to load the 11.2x72 Schuler cartridge, which may turn out to be for a caliber I don't have.

Fortunately I didn't have to buy bullets because I already swage custom .439 dia. bullets for my 11.15x58R Austrian Werndl rifles.

Although I will do a chamber cast if its an 11mm, a simple "look" at the chamber and the muzzle will reveal if its an ordinary 8x57I caliber.





lancaster
(.470 member)
26/02/23 12:14 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

I remember a 11,2x60 Schüler rifle by Mahrhold too, maybe

if its a 8x57 I would say this is deception


Huvius
(.416 member)
26/02/23 01:09 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

If it is an 8mm then send it back. Demand a refund.

Same thing happened to me last year with what was supposed to be a muzzle loading 10bore with a shiny bore which turned out to be a 15 bore with a sewer pipe for a barrel!

The auctioneer wasn't happy but the fact was quite clear that the description wasn't even close to the actual item.


buckstix
(.400 member)
26/02/23 02:08 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello
Thanks for the reply.

If it turns out to be an 8x57 I will definitely send it back. Then hope to find someone that will buy the 11.2x72 dies and brass. With the 11.2x72 being such a rare caliber, that may prove to be a problem.


buckstix
(.400 member)
28/02/23 04:15 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello All,

Thanks again ... I don't have the rifle in hand yet. In fact it still hasn't been shipped. I've been worried sick waiting to find out what I bought. I have since reviewed the pictures again and found some stampings on the bolt handle. Looks like a "crown" and a "crown/N" and perhaps a faint "eagle" above. I've shown the picture below, but its pretty blurry because I had to enhance and enlarge the image. Any comments, or if this tells any additional information? thanks



kuduae
(.400 member)
28/02/23 09:37 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

The CROWN - crown/N proofmarks were the standard German smokeless proofs for a proofload using the "4000 atm special proof powder". As this proof was used for many chamberings pre-WW1, it tells nothing about caliber.

buckstix
(.400 member)
28/02/23 10:45 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

The CROWN - crown/N proofmarks were the standard German smokeless proofs for a proofload using the "4000 atm special proof powder". As this proof was used for many chamberings pre-WW1, it tells nothing about caliber.



Hello kuduae,
thanks for the reply.

Would you know if Johann Peterlongo (or his company) was building sporters "after" WWI, using prewar Mauser actions as a basis for their custom rifles?

I'm told the rifle has shipped. I might have the answer as to caliber in the next day or so.


DarylS
(.700 member)
28/02/23 10:48 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Fingers and toes & eyeballs crossed.

themauserkid
(.275 member)
28/02/23 10:56 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

The top down view of the receiver and barrel shank looks too small IMO, the 11.2 rifles’ barrel shank is barely smaller than the nominal diameter of a large ring 98.

buckstix
(.400 member)
28/02/23 02:00 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

The top down view of the receiver and barrel shank looks too small IMO, the 11.2 rifles’ barrel shank is barely smaller than the nominal diameter of a large ring 98.


Hello themauserkid,
Thanks for the reply.

I searched several pictures of 11.2x72 rifles. It looks close but can't tell. I did find a couple rifles in 11.2x60 that look very similar to mine. And also found a few in 10.75x68 that look similar.


DarylS
(.700 member)
28/02/23 04:26 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

I wondered about 10.75 X 68mm.

3DogMike
(.400 member)
01/03/23 08:10 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

There were all sorts of 10.75mm up to 11.2mm rimless in those days. Anyones guess until such time as Buck gets it in hand.
10.75x57 Mauser would be interesting, tho likely problematic to headspace.

- Mike


buckstix
(.400 member)
01/03/23 10:02 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello All,
Thanks for the reply.

Have you heard the saying "butter side down" ... it refers to when you drop a piece of buttered bread, it always seems to land "butter side down". Well this purchase is "butter side down".

Its an 8x57I. What colossal waste of time and money. Here are pictures of all the markings. I can understand that an auction house doesn't do a chamber cast, but a simple $1 gauge would have saved a lot of time and disappointment. And to top it off, I'm out another $500 because I went and bought a set of 11.2x72 loading dies, and 100 pcs of 11.2x72 brass for this rifle. So .... anyone got an 11.2x72 for sale?



3DogMike
(.400 member)
01/03/23 12:15 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Well Buck, that is a “revolting development” to say the least…….

As an aside; looking at your chamber cast, what do you suppose the deal is with the leade/throat? Looks like at least 1” of freebore or even case neck outside diameter ahead of the case mouth.
- Mike


buckstix
(.400 member)
01/03/23 01:33 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

Well Buck, that is a “revolting development” to say the least…….

As an aside; looking at your chamber cast, what do you suppose the deal is with the leade/throat? Looks like at least 1” of freebore or even case neck outside diameter ahead of the case mouth.
- Mike


Hello 3DogMike,
Thanks for the reply.

As per their auction listing - it said ...... "Bore is very good with light wear" That's another bunch of crap! There is no rifling for the first 1-1/2" in the throat, and as you noted, throat is burned out to case mouth diameter, and same goes for the last 1" at the muzzle, that's also void of any rifling. The rest of the barrel is shallow 4-groove that is rough. If they can't get the caliber right, why would one believe anything else they said about the bore.


DarylS
(.700 member)
01/03/23 01:41 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Very disappointing indeed. Can you send it back? I would never trust anything from that auction house or any auction house they recommended.
Misrepresentation in the very slightest. Fraudulent sale is what it is.


buckstix
(.400 member)
01/03/23 03:13 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello DarylS,
Thanks for the reply.

Yes, they will take it back - no hesitation. They are suppose to send a return label. We'll see if they also refund the $125 shipping that I paid. They said it will be relisted with the correct information in their April auction. We'll see how high it goes next time. Bummer is still the $500 I'm out for buying brass and dies for 11.2x72 caliber. I posted a Want Ad looking for any rifle in that caliber, now that I have dies and brass. Like I said, what a colossal waist of time and money this has been.


eagle27
(.400 member)
01/03/23 03:46 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

That's a bummer, is the rifle worth keeping and having it bored and chambered for something else, is there enough meat in the barrel for 11.2mm?

lancaster
(.470 member)
01/03/23 04:34 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

very sad end

kuduae
(.400 member)
01/03/23 09:21 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

That 8x57I rifle is a collecto’s item in it’s own right. It’s an early Suhl made Mauser, built on a Mauser, Oberndorf commercial action. The Mauser serial number 11927 dates the action to 1905. It was originally proofed in Suhl. As the German proofs were not accepted in Austria then, R.Mahrholdt, owner of the Peterlongo shop, had it reproofed by the Ferlach proofhouse in 1906. So the rifle is as old as Jim Corbett’s famous Rigby Mauser. The long leade in the barrel was a common feature of 8x57I barrels to accommodate the long, cylindrical 227 gr bulles. Even today the CIP prescribes a 42 mm = 1.65” long freebore from case mouth to rifling for 8x57I chambers.
"You never pay too much for something, you only buy it too early. Buying something unseen and unknown may get really expensive.”


buckstix
(.400 member)
01/03/23 11:53 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

That's a bummer, is the rifle worth keeping and having it bored and chambered for something else, is there enough meat in the barrel for 11.2mm?


hello eagle27,
thanks for the reply.

The barrel is much to thin to re-bore to any larger caliber.

Quote:

That 8x57I rifle is a collecto’s item in it’s own right. It’s an early Suhl made Mauser, built on a Mauser, Oberndorf commercial action. The Mauser serial number 11927 dates the action to 1905. It was originally proofed in Suhl. As the German proofs were not accepted in Austria then, R.Mahrholdt, owner of the Peterlongo shop, had it reproofed by the Ferlach proofhouse in 1906. So the rifle is as old as Jim Corbett’s famous Rigby Mauser. The long leade in the barrel was a common feature of 8x57I barrels to accommodate the long, cylindrical 227 gr bulles. Even today the CIP prescribes a 42 mm = 1.65” long freebore from case mouth to rifling for 8x57I chambers.
"You never pay too much for something, you only buy it too early. Buying something unseen and unknown may get really expensive.”


Hello kuduae,
Thanks for the reply.

I didn't think I was buying a complete unknown rifle since the listing stated 11mm caliber in 4 places in the description. I would have been happy with "any" 11mm caliber. If the rifle was in better condition I might consider keeping it, but I paid over $3,150 and I don't believe its worth that much. I am not sure what a reasonable value would be to make the auction house an offer for me to keep it and not send it back for a refund.


lancaster
(.470 member)
02/03/23 03:00 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

you are right, its a good rifle but 3150$ is a fraud with the data given

mckinney
(.400 member)
02/03/23 05:32 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

I am reminded of a section in African Rifles & Cartridges where one of Taylor's hunting companions loved the 8x57 Mauser and the .450-400 and invariably carried one cartridge of each in his pocket. No doubt the 8x57 was with the 227 grain bullet.

You might consider keeping the rifle, particularly if the auction house is willing to reimburse some part of the price.

The 8x57 with 227 grain bullet is a big game rifle in my view, but of course not a big bore rifle.

Of course if it is out of line with the theme of your collection, that is a deal breaker.


lancaster
(.470 member)
02/03/23 07:09 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

the price was over the market value

buckstix
(.400 member)
02/03/23 08:57 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello all
Thanks for the reply/

The auction house offered a $200 refund if I wanted to keep it ... or a full refund if I return it ....

it went back today ..... another lesson learned ... oh well ...

By the way I've got another Mauser coming tomorrow from a different auction house ... I'll start a new post about that one tomorrow.


DarylS
(.700 member)
02/03/23 12:30 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Looking forward to the new post.

NitroXAdministrator
(.700 member)
02/03/23 07:20 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

I am reminded of a section in African Rifles & Cartridges where one of Taylor's hunting companions loved the 8x57 Mauser and the .450-400 and invariably carried one cartridge of each in his pocket. No doubt the 8x57 was with the 227 grain bullet.

...

The 8x57 with 227 grain bullet is a big game rifle in my view, but of course not a big bore rifle.




A .318 or .323 calibre 227 gr bullet would have similar penetration of the .318 WR, .330 250 gr.

I like the rifle purchased. $3150 might not be unusual on our excessively priced usedguns site here ... If people get what's asked for on that site I'm priced out of the market.

Buckstix, you have to be more like me. Look for brass, dies etc 20 years after buying a rifle ...

Looking forward to your new thread. Btw please report back what this rifle sells for as a 8x57. Out of interest.

Please leave the images up. I'll copy them to the NE server when I can. It's a good example of the sort of rifle it should have been correctly labelled as.


93x64mm
(.416 member)
02/03/23 09:57 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Sorry to hear that you got 'stung' Buckstix!
The rifle certainly looked quite nice in my eyes & rare as kuduae explained; but if its not what the auctioneer said it was then you certainly have a case to send it back.
Lets hope your next foray nets something far closer to the mark for you!


buckstix
(.400 member)
03/03/23 12:09 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

Looking forward to your new thread. Btw please report back what this rifle sells for as a 8x57. Out of interest.

Please leave the images up. I'll copy them to the NE server when I can. It's a good example of the sort of rifle it should have been correctly labelled as.


Hello NitroX
Thanks for the reply.

The rifle is suppose to be re-listed in their April Auction. I hope they mention the bore condition honestly. Be sure to mention that if you show my pictures. I will not be bidding on it because of the poor bore condition.

btw ... I always keep my images up - forever.

Quote:

Sorry to hear that you got 'stung' Buckstix!
The rifle certainly looked quite nice in my eyes & rare as kuduae explained; but if its not what the auctioneer said it was then you certainly have a case to send it back.
Lets hope your next foray nets something far closer to the mark for you!


Hello 93x64mm
Thanks for the reply.

Yes, it was sent back yesterday. Although the bore was less than desirable, I would have been happy with it if it had been an 11mm. ... but not as an 8x57.

I also want to give a special "thank you" to kuduae for his help in explaining about the rifle.


NitroXAdministrator
(.700 member)
03/03/23 12:21 AM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Quote:

I will not be bidding on it because of the poor bore condition.






I missed that earlier. Certainly different to the auction description.


buckstix
(.400 member)
03/03/23 12:15 PM
Re: HELP IDENTIFY - WHAT DID I BUY? - Johann Peterlongo 11mm

Hello All,

Like I said earlier, I got another Mauser today from a different action house ..

here's the link under the title "German Gunsmith Modified Model 98 Mauser"

http://forums.nitroexpress.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Number=374717&an=0&page=0#Post374717

and here's the very HAPPY ENDING to the 11mm Mauser saga ... everything turned out far, far better than
I ever expected.

http://forums.nitroexpress.com/showflat.php?Cat=0&Number=374726&an=0&page=0#Post374726



Contact Us NitroExpress.com

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.5


Home | Ezine | Forums | Links | Contact


Copyright 2003 to 2011 - all rights reserved