Wayne, I'm confused....???????
In your Saturday the 19th 5:08AM post you referenced: "......When I checked with Shiloh...."

Then in your next post of Saturday the 19th 5:59AM you referenced: "........Both my C Sharps are really nice guns but......"

Since Shiloh and "C Sharps Arms" are totally separate companies, have you had issues with both or just a typo and the issues were brand specific?
None of the current makers of 1874 Sharps type rifles are immune to screw ups; I had a "pre-Bryan" Shiloh in .50 2 1/2" made for me years ago back when Wolf Droege still owned the company.......big burr at the chamber rim recess as delivered...same deal, there was no way it could have been "test fired" before it was shipped.

That said, I think the Shiloh is at the top of the heap; just have to swallow the price and delivery time.......and the excessive expense of importing a Shiloh for those guys in Oz, Canada or elsewhere makes the Italian rifles very attractive.

For a "user grade" target or hunting rifle my experience is that the Pedersoli's are perfectly fine.
- Mike