If you haven't tried the Macallan, you should. Mmm.

Followed by Lagavulin, Balvenie, Oban...I think The Balvenie wins a lot of the taste tests, but to my taste, the Macallan smokes em all.

Speaking of smoke...if one is in a masochistic mood, Laphroaig has its place too

Old tires, smoke, and Peat was one friend's description