mickey
(.416 member)
05/02/12 03:34 PM
Re: Double of the Day - a bit of controversy

Quote:

this is an example of over-engineering a device which was already developed to the point of being elegant, reliable, intuitive and serviceable over 100yrs ago.

RE HIGH PRESSURE CARTRIDGES, or even any cartridges,
Holland found that out which is why you have the nice bolstered action on the sidelocks after they found the original (I think AB) Action couldn't take it.

Hideous!!

thanks for the explanation of how everything works. it sounds like it's a damn complicated mechanism to build. chuckT.
__________________



Franz Jaeger and many other gun designers through time would not, of course, agree that this system is "over- engineered." This system stands alone as being one of the best systems ever developed for double rifles, due to its strength in containing firing forces. No other double rifle system ever developed has the strength of this Jaeger system, so that alone speaks well for the system. Bolsters on more traditional actions simply don't strengthen them enough to equal the strength of this Jaeger system. It is not a complicated mechanism at all; that is part of its "beauty," but IS complicated to explain it well. It is "hideous," only in the eyes of the beholder, and that brings up the point you are all reflecting, this system is not acceptable to you all, because of its appearance. Thus you all, in your ignorance, poke fun at something just because you don't find it pretty!




doubleriflejack

No offense to Franz Jaeger but you have to admit, for the strongest Double Rifle Action made, you don't see many of them. Perhaps in small cartridges they would be wonderful. Perhaps trying to extract by finger or tilting the cases hoping they fall out with out hitting the standing breach will not be an issue. Perhaps trying to load new ones with nervous finger, under the hood into the right place will not be a problem. Perhaps

In a DGR it could, and probably would if used enough, be a disaster.



Contact Us NitroExpress.com

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.5


Home | Ezine | Forums | Links | Contact


Copyright 2003 to 2011 - all rights reserved