The Cap and I are together on this one. I always found Keith's books, and his antics (shooting at the crapper makes him okay in my book) but would I pay more to have one of his guns? No. TR is a different story and with all due respect to Elmer, he was not a justly-well considered ex US President. (And there is little cache to a gun owned by Warren Harding or Cal Coolidge.) Plus, as the Cap also points out, how does one establish the provenance later when it is time to sell?

Sure, someone ponyed up for an otherwise cheap revolver as you point out. However, not me and not as many as would do so for a TR gun.

Dave