Definitely go with the Ruger. I have one in 416 Rigby, and it was great out of the box. It had fairly nice wood, trigger pull set at a crisp 2 3/4 pouncs, and balances very nicely.It is a bit heavy, but I like that in a big bore. The only modifactions I did to it, was replace the front site with a fiber optic one from NECG. It shoots 400 grain Woodleigh softs and solids inside an inch at one hundred yards.