I think you would be better off just saving a little longer and going with a reputable/long standing outfitter in a proven area at the right time of year. A lot of the "cheap" hunts I have seen are lacking in one or more of these aspects. Another way to get a bargain hunt is to wait for a late cancellation with a reputable outfiter.

I would be very wary before booking with a no name outfitter, just not worth the risk to me. You end up having so much invested in a hunt, both financially and otherwise, that it just doesn't make sense to make a decision primarily on price.