No question about the results - Buffalo wins the overall contest!

Dangerous game status - Buffalo, lion, cow elephant, hippo {on land}

Difficulty of hunt [work/energy expended] - Buffalo, Elephant

Trophy visual quality - Buffalo, Bull Elephant

Quintessential Africa-ism-Buffalo, Bull Elephant, Black Rhino

Unpredictability - Buffalo, Black Rhino

Availability - Buffalo, Leopard

Scarcity - Pangolin

Value for dollar (ROI) - Buffalo,

Winner - Buffalo