I like rimmed shells personally for S rifles. No real good reason, because the best extractors will not break, and they work fine, but I like the "rimmed guns" because they seem smoother to me, and there are a lot of the older style shells to choose from.

219 Zipper
225 Win
25-35 Win
7X65R
30-30 Win
30-40 Krag
7.62X54Russian
30R Balser
303 Brit
348 Winchester
9.3X74R
45-70
450-400
450 Nitro
470 Nitro
500 Nitro

I believe that this list covers about any game I can think of to hunt.
Doesn't make me right and anyone else wrong. It's just what I like.