Years ago, Uberti were the best out of Italy. Now, I don't know which is better, but seems to me, it depends on the gun. I have been told quite bluntly, that the Uberti Model 1876's are the best. My bro has a Pedersoi Colt Lightening and it's super. I think maybe his Henry is also a Pedersoli.

I do know the Chiappa 76's are not even closely as good - I wasn't impressed. Not sure who makes the Chiappa guns.